Matters discussed by the Trustee Directors in May 2010

A brief report of matters discussed at the most recent committee meeting. Feedback on Society matters is welcomed on our online ‘Forum’. The report for June’s meeting will be late or skipped.

1. SMBC has invited the Society to participate in a meeting on cycle routes within Knowle, which it is happy to accept, however that meeting has since been postponed.

2. Some members have pressed the Society to engage with Kimberley Developments on possible changes to its current planning application. The TDs did not consider that this was the appropriate action at this time but would ask Kimberley if it wished to consider such a move.

3. Proposals for honorary life members of the Society were considered and would be put to the members at the next AGM.

4. Arrangements for a full involvement with the Festival in the Park on 19th June were agreed.

5. Issues of copyright had been further researched and relevant material gives the Society renewed confidence in the use of its resources.

6. A bold proposal to create a youth committee within the Society was considered and will continue to receive further thought. It was not expected to be an easy or assured development but was seen as a worthy objective to pursue that was in line with the eductaion objects of the Society. Ultimately the Society might not benefit directly from new blood but it did see that it would be a valuable contribution to the civic movement generally. An approach will be made to an identified possible leader of such a committee to sound out the idea. Natural Environment and the proposed development by Kimberley were seen as good areas where youth involvement could be initiated.

7. It was reported that a public enquiry will now be set up on the matter of the refused planning application for canal moorings at Jacobean Lane. It was reported that SMBC has lost alll the initial public objections; the Sociey will be reiterating its initial objections. It will also be inviting members through its newsletter to let it know of their points of view.

8. The Trustee Directors approved purchase of a stock of linen bags with the Society’s logo and a local scene to be sold at close to cost price at forthcoming public events and as publicity for the Society.

9. The TD’s received with great regret the news of the death of Jean Laughton, a bulk distributor of the newsletter.

Objection to Kimberley Developments Planning Application

The Society recognises that there is a need for sympathetic enhancement of the area between the High Street and St John’s Close and that there are elements of this proposal that go some way to achieving that. However, the numerous and significant concerns that we have over the details of this application mean that we must object to it.

The Knowle Society objects to this application on the following grounds:

  • The size and scale of the store are inappropriate in relation to the Conservation Area and to the size of the site available. It is also too large having regard to the Council’s own retail evidence base which shows that capacity exists in Knowle only for a smaller store.
  • Car parking and servicing arrangements are totally inadequate leading to traffic congestion, safety concerns and amenity impacts, particularly for residents in St John’s Close.
  • The replacement bungalows would have an unacceptable level of amenity.


Matters discussed by the Trustee Directors in April 2010

A brief report of matters discussed at the most recent committee meeting. Feedback on Society matters is welcomed on our online ‘Forum’.

1. Planning Applications for St John’s Close by Kimberley Developments – The Directors received a report from the Society’s Planning Committee which had assessed the applications, the input from the public meeting and the feedback from both response forms and the Society’s web Forum. The Planning Committee held both extremes of personal opinion on the applications but its chairman paid tribute to the professional manner in which the matter was considered and the fact that the committee came to a unanimous decision on the response that it was recommending to the Trustee Directors (TDs). The TDs accepted the report and authorised that it be submitted to the Council as the Society’s official response. As soon as the report has been sent to the Council it will also be released on the Society’s website. In addition to the official response there will also be supporting information from the Society that expresses additional opinions which are not admissible as formal responses to a planning application but reflect some of the more subjective views. Meanwhile the Society will be making formal enquiry from the Council on the ownership of land for the Village Hall and bungalows. It will also be considering seriously creating a Village Plan (a.k.a. Village Design Statement) as a positive preparation for any revision to the applications that might be possible should the current plans be rejected by the Council.

2. Golden Jubilee 2012 – The Society was investigating suitable memorabilia with a local flavour that would help the community celebrate the Society’s Jubilee year.

3. Copyright – The TDs agreed to take fixed price legal advice on copyright to assist it in the management of its archives and publications.

4. Planning – In addition to the major activity on St John’s Close the committee had remained active in more routine planning matters. In particular it was trying to persuade the Council to make two policies: on retention of retail rather than service properties in the village and on lighting of shop premises. It was also reported that local residents had expressed gratitude to the Society for its assistance in the matter of the temporary classrooms at Arden School. Reassurance had been received that the classrooms would be removed by the end of April and that the site would be tidied and the hedge replaced.

5. New storage and display facilities in the Local History Centre had now been installed and were very well received by the stewards and everyone who had seen them.

6. Progress on the Knowle Green Community Project (bus shelter replacement) was now moving apace. The TDs discussed the probable need to set up a separate company to manage the handling of any grant monies. A report on the process needed to enable the Society to handle such funds will be produced by the Secretary for further discussion.

7. The Society had previously decided that it would not join the new Civic Voice (follow-up to the defunct Civic Trust) as the membership cost was prohibitive for a large Society like ours. Since Civic Voice had now offered a subscription cap of 500 pounds p.a. and recent material emanating from the embryonic organisation was showing signs of being of a high quality and very relevant to the work of The Knowle Society, the TDs now decided to make application to join for one year initially.

Matters discussed by the Trustee Directors in March 2010

A brief report of matters discussed at the most recent committee meeting. Feedback on Society matters is welcomed on our online ‘Forum’.

1. Knowle Green Community Project. The steering group had met on 25th February and was very satisfied that progress was now being made. The architect has now been appointed and Groundwork will be the agent. There is an issue to be clarified on liability for costs before any planning application is approved.

2. An ad-hoc group of Trustee Directors (TDs) had considered possible cycle routes within Knowle. The outcome was not entirely satisfactory and it was agreed that the conclusions will be published in the July newsletter, seeking the opinion of members.

3. Plans for the public meeting on the planning application by Kimberley Developments for St Johns Close were discussed, including arrangements for a leaflet drop to all (or most) properties in Knowle and the subsequent considered submission to the Council by the Society on its findings.

4. The joint celebration in Knowle of the Golden Jubilee of the Society and Diamond Jubilee of the Queen is now a standing item for regular review.

5. A TD indicated that he would be making a proposal to the next meeting, allowed under clause 2.8.6. of the existing Articles of Association, for the nomination of one or more Honorary Members.

6. How to use the Society’s stand at the Knowle Park Festival was considered, with proposals to maintain an active and interesting presence at this important event.

7. A sound understanding of copyright in respect of the Society’s resources was required and the cost of taking formal advice is to be investigated.

8. Reports from committee chairmen were noted, most having been received electronically in advance of the meeting. Councillor Diana Holl-Allen gave a brief update on Council matters as they affected Knowle’s interests.

9. It was noted that the successor organisation to the Civic Trust, Civic Voice, which will be launched shortly, had now recognised our concern about subscriptions as they applied to very large societies like The Knowle Society and was offering a capped fee of 500 pounds, substantially less than previously would have applied to Knowle. It was agreed that the Chairman would provide TDs with a summary of the benefits which The Knowle Society might gain from membership, with a view to a decision being taken at the next meeting.